As far as which sounds better, you should already know that the answer depends on the player's tonal preference. Many use both, which is why many guitarists use multiple types of guitars. But you still have to keep in mind that a large 12-pound guitar might feel uncomfortable after an extended period of playing and if you're not comfortable, you won't be playing your best. So for many, a lighter guitar might be their preference simply because it feels better while playing, regardless of sound quality.
The Importance of TonewoodsThere’s a lot to do with a guitar’s signature tone. There are the pickups, of course, as well as the composition of the wood, not to mention the body type. But beyond that, the weight of the instrument also plays an integral role. And just as there are those who swear by single coils or humbuckers, there’s also debate over what sounds better: a lighter guitar or a heavier one. The south africa email list general consensus among guitarists is that a lighter instrument will resonate better in response to the full spectrum of string vibrations and therefore produce a more musical sound, consisting of brighter highs and a more “open” tone. On the other hand, heavier guitars are generally praised for their richer, fuller sound, which is due to the relatively massive size of the wood used to anchor the pickups, the strings, and in some ways, the tone itself.
Lightweight vs. Heavyweight
And just like going analog or digital, there are good arguments for lighter and heavier guitars with plenty of examples for each. Before the early 80s, it was quite common for a Gibson Les Paul to weigh up to 12 pounds. This heavy axe was responsible for much of the sonic impact, depth, and clarity that can be found in the music of artists like Led Zeppelin, Sex Pistols, AC/DC, and even Boston. Looking at the other side, the popular Fender Stratocaster and Telecaster that dominated in the early 60s each weighed in at 6-7 pounds and are known for being the instrument behind the sounds of classic music by Jimi Hendrix and Pink Floyd, a sound that cannot be denied its greatness. So, with that being said, it is obvious that great classic sounds come from lighter and heavier guitars.